Test Templates
Thursday, May 3, 2007
Central Planning Approach to Cities
If there is one thing that history has taught us it is central planning / communism never works. Even when the intentions are noble nobody can ever anticipate the markets.
With prosperity people would want to live in high rises with 1000 other people. They might want to spread out to suburbs where they can have an independent house. With this demand a new market will be created. And that would be the end of these DeCi's. Over a period of time 50 - 100 years they will become cities like the ones we have today.
I would love such planned cities but I see 2 problems with the approach.
1> Its highly unlikely such cities can be created out of scratch. Cities are born when people can find employment. I am just aware of Chandigarh which was created from scratch and that had government for its employer
2> Even though cities can be planned nobody can anticipate what the future development might bring. Cities have to continually evolve. Look at Chandigarh today, it is congested. Yet when it was created in 50's the designer thought he had more than enough space, parks, wide roads. Who is to say what will happen in future. We might not even travel by cars because everyone will have their own flying cars. Who knows. So to say everybody will travel in train is making an assumption that mode of transport will remain the same. And that is unlikely
Instead I would rather hope the government (central planner) invests in the infrastructure. If the government can provide connectivity (road, air) and energy (electricity) across all the major Indian cities (1 to 5 cities in each state depending on state size) that will in turn ease the pressure on the metro's making them more livable.
Wednesday, April 18, 2007
Diversification - Take 2
"HDFC prudence, not being an index fund, would be investing in much more risky stocks."He goes on to add:
"One must take into consideration the Risk involved in the so called 'diversification'.And finally:
HDFC prudence has given better results by taking Higher Risks. I don’t think there is any thing novel in that. It is almost a Tautology"
"'Diversification', as you define in this article’, seems to be inconsistent with 'Diversification' that the investing world generally believes in i.e. picking up funds to minimize risks and not maximize profits."I generally agree with his rationale but have some reservations. First HDFC Prudence is a hybrid fund. Therefore, by definition a portion of its portfolio is invested in Debt / Bond markets which are inherently less risky than stock. Therefore, the fund could have some of the stocks which were more risky than Sensex but overall its portfolio would be less risky. This is somewhat indicated by the fact that it had very little down years.
Second, I do agree with the fact that diversification is generally done to avoid risk. However, unlike him, I believe diversification can also give rise to higher returns (for the same risk taken). This can happen when the portfolio is made up of negatively co-related instruments i.e. when one goes up the other goes down. This is what the efficient frontier in portfolio theory is all about. The following excerpt is from the moneychimp explains it clearly
The second important property of the efficient frontier is that it's curved, not straight. This is actually significant -- in fact, it's the key to how diversification lets you improve your reward-to-risk ratio.To see why, imagine a 50/50 allocation between just two securities. Assuming that the year-to-year performance of these two securities is not perfectly in sync -- that is, assuming that the great years and the lousy years for Security 1 don't correspond perfectly to the great years and lousy years for Security 2, but that their cycles are at least a little off -- then the standard deviation of the 50/50 allocation will be less than the average of the standard deviations of the two securities separately. Graphically, this stretches the possible allocations to the left of the straight line joining the two securities.
All said, I concur that lower risk and not higher returns is the primary reason for diversification. Also, practically, its very difficult to find negatively co-related securities.
I agree that looking only at HDFC Prudence is not the correct way to look at the virtues of diversification. The results confirm that for higher returns you need to take higher risk. But then they also give an historical indication of how the results in India have been.
However, what I intend to do in this post (as in previous post) is try to look at diversification in different instruments and not just diversification in stocks.
I will choose a simple portfolio made up of Sensex and Bank Deposits. I will invest a fixed amount of Rs 1000 at the begining of every year (no market timing). I will consider 5 different portfolio's of 100%, 70%, 50%, 30% and 0% stocks. For bank deposits I will consider 1 year returns. The results are:
| 100% Stocks | 70% Stocks | 50% Stocks | 30% Stocks | 0% Stocks | |
| 1991 | 85.80% | 63.66% | 48.90% | 34.14% | 12.00% |
| 1992 | 33.62% | 28.16% | 23.99% | 19.28% | 11.00% |
| 1993 | 27.82% | 23.73% | 20.51% | 16.79% | 10.00% |
| 1994 | 14.26% | 13.54% | 12.97% | 12.29% | 11.00% |
| 1995 | -20.45% | -13.16% | -7.36% | -0.59% | 12.00% |
| 1996 | -0.93% | 2.69% | 5.15% | 7.66% | 11.50% |
| 1997 | 18.16% | 15.83% | 14.33% | 12.87% | 10.75% |
| 1998 | -16.48% | -8.53% | -3.23% | 2.07% | 10.00% |
| 1999 | 63.32% | 43.98% | 32.72% | 22.54% | 9.00% |
| 2000 | -23.75% | -14.87% | -8.53% | -1.82% | 9.00% |
| 2001 | -18.25% | -9.21% | -3.79% | 1.20% | 8.00% |
| 2002 | 3.53% | 4.18% | 4.51% | 4.79% | 5.13% |
| 2003 | 72.55% | 45.35% | 31.18% | 19.28% | 4.63% |
| 2004 | 12.43% | 10.40% | 9.00% | 7.58% | 5.38% |
| 2005 | 41.82% | 31.99% | 25.06% | 17.80% | 6.25% |
| 2006 | 46.32% | 37.41% | 30.33% | 22.04% | 6.63% |
| Average | 21.24% | 17.20% | 14.73% | 12.37% | 8.89% |
| StdDev | 34.16% | 23.39% | 16.65% | 10.06% | 2.56% |
| Min Returns | -23.75% | -14.87% | -8.53% | -1.82% | 4.63% |
StdErr | 8.54% | 5.85% | 4.16% | 2.52% | 0.64% |
The % age returns for each year indicate by how much the total investment grew (shrunk) during that 1 year period.
The results are not surprising but give an indication of the historical returns of different portfolios. The risk (indicated by StdDev) and the return (indicated by Average) decreases as the %age of stock decreases.
We have to take the average stock market return with a pinch of salt. StdErr is a statistical figure that indicates how close my sample Average is to the real world i.e. by how much will the average vary if I take a different sample. Higher standard error indicates that Average (i.e. returns) may not remain the same in the future.
Now let's look at the results when I balance my portfolio at the beginning of every year i.e. while instead of dividing Rs 1000 every year in stocks and deposits. I add Rs 1000 to the previous year returns and divide the whole amount into stocks and deposits. The results are:
| 100% Stocks | 70% Stocks | 50% Stocks | 30% Stocks | 0% Stocks | |
| 1991 | 85.80% | 63.66% | 48.90% | 34.14% | 12.00% |
| 1992 | 33.62% | 26.83% | 22.31% | 17.79% | 11.00% |
| 1993 | 27.82% | 22.47% | 18.91% | 15.35% | 10.00% |
| 1994 | 14.26% | 13.28% | 12.63% | 11.98% | 11.00% |
| 1995 | -20.45% | -10.72% | -4.23% | 2.26% | 12.00% |
| 1996 | -0.93% | 2.80% | 5.29% | 7.77% | 11.50% |
| 1997 | 18.16% | 15.94% | 14.45% | 12.97% | 10.75% |
| 1998 | -16.48% | -8.54% | -3.24% | 2.06% | 10.00% |
| 1999 | 63.32% | 47.03% | 36.16% | 25.30% | 9.00% |
| 2000 | -23.75% | -13.93% | -7.38% | -0.83% | 9.00% |
| 2001 | -18.25% | -10.38% | -5.13% | 0.12% | 8.00% |
| 2002 | 3.53% | 4.01% | 4.33% | 4.65% | 5.13% |
| 2003 | 72.55% | 52.18% | 38.59% | 25.01% | 4.63% |
| 2004 | 12.43% | 10.32% | 8.91% | 7.50% | 5.38% |
| 2005 | 41.82% | 31.15% | 24.04% | 16.92% | 6.25% |
| 2006 | 46.32% | 34.41% | 26.47% | 18.54% | 6.63% |
| Average | 21.24% | 17.53% | 15.06% | 12.60% | 8.89% |
| StdDev | 34.16% | 23.80% | 16.92% | 10.11% | 2.56% |
| Min Returns | -23.75% | -13.93% | -7.38% | -0.83% | 4.63% |
| StdErr | 8.54% | 5.95% | 4.23% | 2.53% | 0.64% |
Again pretty much similar results. One important observation is the minimum return in all cases is much less than what it would be without balancing.
Finally, have a look at the sheet to find the actual growth in the Rs value. Even though the diversification might reduce your overall returns it makes getting through the bad years a little easier. This makes a difference between your continuing to invest in the stock market or just getting out and not investing for quite some time thereby missing out on the best years.
Have a look at the Min Returns. Pick a portfolio (asset allocation) that matches with your risk profile. If you can withstand 20% loss in any given year (and still continue investing) then 100% diversified stocks is your ideal asset allocation. But if you cannot then you should diversify not only in stocks but in other instruments.
Tuesday, April 17, 2007
Rise of Rupee
Let's look at the impact of currency appreciation more closely. When currency appreciates it is beneficial to the importers as they have to pay less in Re terms for the import. For exporters the reverse is true. Falling currency make their products more expensive. And as a product becomes dearer the sales start to decrease.
India's technology and BPO sector is an export fast growing sector. Most of the jobs are being created in the sector. So, anything which hurts this sector will in turn have an affect on the Indian economy. Therefore, everyone expects RBI to intervene to stop the rise of the Re. However, RBI is more concerned with the rising inflation.
So how does currency appreciation impact inflation. The current rise in inflation is caused by rise in food and fuel prices. India imports its fuel and rising Re will in turn lower the actual price that is paid for these imports. Secondly, as India seeks to import food grain to meet the shortage in food as rising Re will only help.
Therefore, if the import costs are lower then the final retail prices should also be lower. This explains the reluctance of RBI to intervene. They are trying hard to get the inflation in their target zone (ard 5%).
Moreover, even though Re has seen high appreciation in dollar terms it has seen only a slight rise in terms of other currencies (yen, euro, pound). This seems to indicate that the rise can be attributed more to dollar's broad decline against all other currency.
In conclusion, though rise in currency is generally a good sign, the current rise in Re may be due to factors other than the health of the economy / fiscal discipline. This rise has led to various reports indicating that the Re is overvalued by as much as 13-14% and will eventually fall back to 43.5 - 44 range.
Monday, April 2, 2007
Advantages of Diversification
Then after reading my article at seekingalpha Ayush Jain (ayush.jain at gmail.com) sent me an e-mail providing data and analysis for HDFC Prudence fund
HDFC Prudence funds suits our purpose as it has been around since 1994. It is a hybrid fund with equity allocation up to 75%. The fund has done exceedingly well earning 22.66% annualized return since inception. The comparison of the fund with Sensex reveals some interesting insights.
Rs. 10,000 is assumed to be invested on 1st of every month. No money is ever taken out of the funds. The following definitions will help understand the results:
- Period: is the number of years for which money is invested starting in 1991 (for sensex) and 1994 (for HDFC Prudence)
- Minimum Amount: is the Amount after investing for the time period
- Minimum Return: is the return is the annualized return
- % Period of losses: is the number of periods in which you would have sustained losses i.e. for 184 1-year (starting 1991) periods you would have lost money in 71 periods (or 38.59%).
- Total Num of Period: For Sensex it will be 184 1-year period, 172 2-year period etc
| Period (in | Minimum | Maximum | Average | % Period | Total Num | |||
| Amount | Return | Amount | Return | Amount | Return | |||
| 1 | 93,558 | -22.036 | 298,673 | 100.01 | 131,277 | 9.398 | 38.59% | 184 |
| 2 | 165,516 | -22.355 | 418,580 | 43.343 | 276,184 | 9.735 | 36.05% | 172 |
| 3 | 258,896 | -15.601 | 732,196 | 39.975 | 443,826 | 10.838 | 31.25% | 160 |
| 4 | 356,750 | -11.524 | 1,195,186 | 40.069 | 612,856 | 10.017 | 31.08% | 148 |
| 5 | 451,378 | -9.341 | 1,640,058 | 35.637 | 796,161 | 9.582 | 29.41% | 136 |
| 6 | 551,081 | -7.595 | 2,125,649 | 32.031 | 987,335 | 9.097 | 28.23% | 124 |
| 7 | 647,285 | -6.519 | 2,510,623 | 27.702 | 1,185,699 | 8.627 | 28.57% | 112 |
| 8 | 737,201 | -5.902 | 2,906,050 | 24.468 | 1,423,349 | 8.705 | 26.00% | 100 |
| 9 | 874,010 | -4.265 | 3,426,969 | 22.624 | 1,677,642 | 8.704 | 25.00% | 88 |
| 10 | 1,000,028 | -3.343 | 3,878,810 | 20.641 | 1,918,410 | 8.381 | 27.63% | 76 |
| 11 | 1,138,946 | -2.481 | 4,378,743 | 19.132 | 2,280,117 | 8.883 | 20.31% | 64 |
| 12 | 1,317,794 | -1.372 | 4,899,592 | 17.866 | 2,787,753 | 9.819 | 5.77% | 52 |
| 13 | 2,220,463 | 4.931 | 5,319,094 | 16.493 | 3,505,464 | 11.054 | 0.00% | 40 |
| 14 | 3,051,960 | 7.654 | 5,966,176 | 15.776 | 4,395,231 | 12.115 | 0.00% | 28 |
| 15 | 4,822,602 | 11.572 | 6,528,314 | 14.936 | 5,718,946 | 13.472 | 0.00% | 16 |
| 16 | 6,921,864 | 13.922 | 7,659,560 | 14.961 | 7,447,629 | 14.673 | 0.00% | 4 |
HDFC Prudence:
| Period (in | Minimum | Maximum | Average | % Period | Total Num | |||
| Amount | Return | Amount | Return | Amount | Return | |||
| 1 | 101,887 | -15.095 | 213,411 | 77.842 | 132,742 | 10.618 | 28.26% | 138 |
| 2 | 195,750 | -12.841 | 460,299 | 52.134 | 303,572 | 16.726 | 12.70% | 126 |
| 3 | 344,006 | -2.255 | 754,025 | 41.836 | 527,947 | 20.407 | 4.39% | 114 |
| 4 | 505,967 | 2.118 | 1,204,367 | 40.437 | 818,505 | 22.533 | 0.00% | 102 |
| 5 | 663,846 | 3.389 | 1,825,694 | 39.723 | 1,187,117 | 23.681 | 0.00% | 90 |
| 6 | 1,018,150 | 9.992 | 2,424,878 | 36.125 | 1,612,614 | 23.605 | 0.00% | 78 |
| 7 | 1,199,131 | 8.911 | 3,210,332 | 34.117 | 2,174,600 | 23.999 | 0.00% | 66 |
| 8 | 1,656,080 | 12.039 | 4,265,264 | 33.073 | 2,999,177 | 25.171 | 0.00% | 54 |
| 9 | 2,468,701 | 16.238 | 5,464,728 | 31.774 | 4,142,943 | 26.331 | 0.00% | 42 |
| 10 | 3,829,918 | 20.421 | 6,832,374 | 30.475 | 5,442,166 | 26.513 | 0.00% | 30 |
| 11 | 5,854,311 | 23.651 | 8,330,101 | 29.144 | 7,180,273 | 26.827 | 0.00% | 18 |
| 12 | 8,164,429 | 25.058 | 9,537,348 | 27.245 | 8,681,955 | 25.922 | 0.00% | 6 |
I believe it would be best to ignore data for periods that will be most impacted by the current bull rally (2003 - present). As those returns are unlikely to be replicated, at least in the near future. Therefore, I would ignore the results where the Total Number of Period is less than 75 (nothing under 60 in any case).
Looking at the data, HDFC Prudence has consistently averaged around 23%. This is an excellent return considering Sensex has just averaged between 8-9 %. HDFC Prudence price has gone up by 11 times (from 10 to 110) whereas assuming Sensex at 3865.44 (Sensex Jan 23, 1994 close) has only gone up by approx 3 times in 13.25 years.
This analysis does not take into account dividends declared by the Sensex. Whether Index returns would become comparable to HDFC Prudence taking dividends into account is open to debate until I get that data.
I think there are 2 aspects HDFC Prudence performance. 1st fund manager's skills in picking the right stocks and 2nd the mix of Prudence portfolio (contains stocks and bonds). Assuming that market timing is difficult, I would think that some of the returns can be explained by diversification offered by multiple asset classes in HDFC Prudence.